Business Incubators vs Accelerators: Key Differences

Business incubators vs accelerators compared on stage, length, funding, equity and selection, with the real Y Combinator and Techstars deal terms and a checklist to pick the right one for your startup.

Smiling startup founders working together at a table in a coworking space
Photo: Pexels

Should you join an incubator or an accelerator? An incubator helps you shape an early idea into a business over months or years, usually for little or no equity. An accelerator takes a startup that already has a product and some users. It invests money for a share of the company. Then it pushes the team to grow fast in a fixed program of about three months.

We compared the two models using the published deal terms of two well-known accelerators. We also looked at the free help from the US Small Business Development Center network. The table comes first, then the details behind each difference and a checklist to help you choose.

Incubators vs Accelerators at a Glance

FactorBusiness incubatorStartup accelerator
StageIdea or very early businessProduct built, early users or revenue
LengthOpen-ended, often months to yearsFixed, often about three months
FundingUsually none, sometimes small grantsCash investment on acceptance
EquityOften none, or a small shareUsually a share of the company
CostRent or membership fees in some programsUsually no fee, paid for with equity
SelectionRolling admission, moderateCompetitive cohorts
Main benefitSpace, advice and time to buildSpeed, mentors, investor network
Ends withGraduation when readyDemo day for investors

What a Business Incubator Does

A business incubator gives early founders a place to work and support while they figure out the business. Many are run by colleges, towns, development groups or nonprofits. Some focus on one sector, such as food, biotech or manufacturing.

Typical incubator support includes:

  • Workspace, such as desks, labs, kitchens or workshops at a lower cost.
  • Business advice on planning, legal setup and finance.
  • Workshops and mentoring from local experts.
  • Shared services, such as reception, internet and meeting rooms.
  • Introductions to banks, local investors and grant programs.

Many incubators exist to grow the local economy, so they often take no equity. Instead, they may charge rent or membership fees. The pace is slower. That helps founders who are still testing an idea or building a product.

What a Startup Accelerator Does

An accelerator works in batches, also called cohorts. A group of startups starts on the same day, works through an intensive program and ends with a demo day where founders pitch to investors. In return for cash and support, the accelerator takes a share of each company.

The two best-known programs publish their terms, which makes them a useful benchmark.

Techstars investment terms page with the $220,000 accelerator deal
Screenshot: techstars.com
ProgramInvestmentHow it is structuredProgram length
Y Combinator$500,000$125,000 post-money SAFE for 7%, plus a $375,000 uncapped MFN SAFEBatch program
Techstars$220,000$200,000 uncapped MFN Safe, plus a $20,000 agreement that converts into 5% common stock3 months

Y Combinator says its investment is not tied to milestones and that it charges no fees. Techstars pays its $220,000 at acceptance into a program, and its Asia-Pacific programs use a smaller $100,000 MFN Safe instead.

Key Differences Between Incubators and Accelerators

Stage of the Startup

Incubators accept founders with an idea, a prototype or a very new business. Accelerators usually want a working product, a committed team and early signs that customers want it. If you have no product yet, an incubator is usually the better first step.

Funding and Equity

This is the biggest difference. Accelerators invest cash and take equity. For example, Techstars’ $20,000 agreement converts into 5% of the company, and YC’s $125,000 SAFE converts into 7%. Most incubators give no cash and take no equity, though some charge rent.

Length and Pace

An accelerator runs on a fixed calendar, often about three months, with weekly goals and frequent check-ins. An incubator lets you stay until you are ready, which can be months or years.

Selection

Top accelerators get far more applications than they accept. Incubators often take people all year, with simple forms and short interviews.

Outcome

Accelerators end with a demo day aimed at raising a seed round. Incubators end when the business is stable enough to move into its own space.

Founders presenting a startup pitch at a whiteboard
Photo: Pexels

Pros and Cons of Each Model

Neither model is better in every case. Each one gives you something and asks for something back.

ModelProsCons
IncubatorLow cost, little or no equity, time to learn, shared space and toolsSlower pace, little or no funding, smaller investor network
AcceleratorCash on day one, fast progress, mentors, demo day, alumni networkGives up equity, very competitive, intense schedule, fixed dates

For example, a food startup that needs a licensed kitchen and time to test recipes gains more from an incubator. A software startup with paying users and a plan to raise a seed round may gain more from an accelerator.

Questions to Ask Before You Sign Up

Program quality varies a lot, so ask direct questions before you commit. Good programs are happy to answer.

  • What exactly do you take? Ask for the equity share, the instrument and any fees in writing.
  • Who are the mentors? Ask how often you will meet them and what they have built.
  • What happened to past companies? Ask for a list of alumni and talk to two or three founders.
  • Which investors attend demo day? Ask how many past companies raised money after the program.
  • What support continues afterward? Some programs keep helping alumni for years, while others stop on demo day.

Free Alternatives Worth Knowing

Not every founder needs either program. In the US, the SBA’s Small Business Development Centers offer free business advising, mentoring and training through more than 900 local centers. Their help covers business plans, financing, exporting, ecommerce and compliance.

Coworking spaces, university entrepreneurship centers and online founder communities can also give you a network without giving up equity. Our startup compliance checklist covers the paperwork you need either way.

How to Choose Between an Incubator and an Accelerator

Answer these questions honestly before you apply.

  1. Do you have a product people use? If not, start in an incubator or a free program.
  2. Do you need cash now? Accelerators invest money; most incubators do not.
  3. Are you ready to give up equity? Work out what 5% to 10% means at your next round.
  4. Can your team commit full time for three months? Accelerators expect intense focus.
  5. Do you need special facilities? Labs, kitchens and workshops are more common in incubators.
  6. Where are your investors? An accelerator with a large investor network can shorten fundraising.

If you choose an accelerator, plan your next steps early. Our guides to SAFE notes and startup exit strategies explain what the paperwork means for your future.

Questions About Incubators and Accelerators

Can a startup join both an incubator and an accelerator?

Yes. Many founders start in an incubator to build the first product, then apply to an accelerator once they have traction.

Do incubators take equity?

Many do not, especially those run by universities, governments and nonprofits. Some private incubators take a small share or charge fees, so read the agreement.

Is an accelerator worth the equity?

It can be when the money, mentors and investor network speed up growth more than you could alone. Compare the value of the deal with the share you give up, and talk to founders who went through the program.

Joydeep Bhattacharya Avatar

Written by

Founder, Editor and Business Reporter, Bizolaunch

Keep Reading